Facial plastic surgery in men enhances perception of attractiveness, trustworthiness
Listen to this article
I may have to have some plastic surgery because of a rather nasty bit of cancer on my nose (I’ll know by the time you read this) so I was particularly interested in this study. In the first of a kind study, plastic surgeons found that when a man chose to have a nip or a tuck on his face, it significantly increased perceptions of attractiveness, likeability, social skills, or trustworthiness.
The study, published in JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, shows that men benefit from facial cosmetic surgery in much the same way as women: other people find more to like in that new visage. However, the study did not show a significant impact on perceptions of gender (masculinity), whereas a similar study performed with women in 2015 showed a significant increase in ratings of femininity.
What the researchers say: “The tendency to judge facial appearance is likely rooted in evolution, as studies suggest evaluating a person based on appearance is linked to survival—our animal instinct tells us to avoid those who are ill-willed and we know from previous research that personality traits are drawn from an individual's neutral expressions,” explains the study's senior investigator.
“Taken together, our findings suggest that both men and women undergoing facial cosmetic surgery can experience not only improved perception of attractiveness, but other positive changes in society's perception of their persona,” he says.
In recent years, men in America have changed their social attitudes about “appearance maintenance” from one bordering on narcissism to somewhere on a continuum of well-being, he adds. Men are now 15-20% of the cosmetic surgery market, but many preferred male facial features are the opposite of what is prized on a female face. For example, it is believed that attractive male features include prominent cheekbones, a square jaw and prominent chin, while attractive female features are round cheeks, softer contours, wide smile and large, wide eyes.
(As a former TV director/producer I must tell you that these “female attributes” are not at all photogenic).
In this study, 24 men underwent facial cosmetic surgery by one of two (male) Georgetown surgeons. The men had one or more of the following surgeries: upper eyelid lift (upper blepharoplasty), reduction of lower eyelids (lower blepharoplasty), face-lift, brow-lift, neck-lift, nose reshaping (rhinoplasty), and/or a chin implant (and who said narcissism was dead?).
These men, who paid for their own surgery, agreed to the use of their before and after photographs for research purposes (more narcissism). Six surveys were designed, each of which included eight photographs (four before surgery, four after surgery. No survey contained both of a single individual).
More than 150 participants (mostly white, between the ages of 25-34, and with a college degree) who reviewed the photos were not told of the study's intent. They were asked to rate their perception of each patient's personality traits (aggressiveness, extroversion, likeability, risk-seeking, sociability, trustworthiness), attractiveness and masculinity.
The research team built a complex multivariate linear mixed model to be able to assess participants' reaction to a specific surgical procedure—rhinoplasty (nose job), for example—while controlling for changes from additional procedures done on other areas of the face.
Researchers found that chin augmentation was the only procedure that did not have an effect on perceived attractiveness, masculinity or personality. The authors believe this was due to the low number of study patients undergoing this procedure. The other procedures showed the following changes, among others:
- Upper eyelid -- increased likeability and trustworthiness
- Lower eyelid -- decreased risk-taking
- Brow-lift -- improved perception of extroversion and risk-taking
- Face-lift -- increased likeability and trustworthiness
- Neck-lift -- increased perceived extroversion and masculinity
- Nose -- improved attractiveness
(And, of course overall narcissism!)
The statistically significant findings overall reflected increases in attractiveness, likeability, social skills and trustworthiness.
“It is really interesting that different anatomic areas of the face have varying degrees of contribution to overall personality perception,” the lead author (another plastic surgeon) says. “And it is also noteworthy that the study did not find a significant change in masculinity. Just one procedure, a neck-lift, was found to enhance that trait.
“This suggests that the current menu of cosmetic procedures for men are likely not as gender-enhancing as they are for women,” he says. The earlier study in women examined the same cosmetic procedures in 30 white females and found a significant increase in femininity for many of the procedures.
“Cicero described the face as the 'mirror of the soul’, meaning that a person's physical appearance is the personal characteristic most obvious and accessible to others in social interaction—so it's not surprising that subtle changes in facial appearances are powerful enough to alter judgments of personality,” the researchers said.
They commented that more study is needed in order for cosmetic surgery to reach its full potential. “Optimizing patient outcomes will require a broader understanding of the potential changes in social perception that can occur with surgery.”
So, what? Whatever you think of men who have plastic surgery to enhance appearance, rather than for medical reasons, it’s an illuminating study. It shows, once again, how much we judge character and ability by the face. In itself this is nothing new and dates from the very beginnings of our species when we looked for beauty of a certain kind in women as a sign of their child-bearing ability and for manliness in men as a sign that they could protect and look after the resulting brood.
Join the discussion
More from this issue of TR
You might be interested inBack to Today's Research
When job seekers are "overqualified," gender bias may come into play
Hiring managers are suspicious about overqualified male candidates’ motivations; they’re deemed “flight risks” and passed over for fear that they’ll decamp for better opportunities. But overqualified women are more likely to be hired despite their excessive qualifications.
Psychology, and psychometrics suffer from WEIRD science.
For decades, the consensus among psychologists (and those who frame psychometric tests) was that a cluster of five personality traits openness, conscientiousness, agreeableness, extraversion and neuroticism —or a slight variation thereof—universally defines the structure of human personality. However, when the team behind this research studied the Tsimane, an isolated indigenous population in the Bolivian Amazon, they found not five broad dimensions of personality, but two—prosociality and industriousness. Perhaps the Big Five aren’t so universal after all.
Join our tribe
Subscribe to Dr. Bob Murray’s Today’s Research, a free weekly roundup of the latest research in a wide range of scientific disciplines. Explore leadership, strategy, culture, business and social trends, and executive health.