Low income and work stress contribute to link between education, heart disease and stroke
Listen to this article
Low educational levels predict an increased risk of developing or dying from heart disease and stroke according to the first nationwide study of the link between education and risk of cardiovascular disease.
The study, which is published in the European Heart Journal is also the first nationwide study to look at the extent to which low income and work stress play a role in the association between education and cardiovascular disease. It found that low income and work stress could explain between 21-54% of the increased risk of developing or dying from cardiovascular disease among people with and without cardiovascular or metabolic diseases at the start of the study.
Researchers analyzed data from 1,638,270 Danish residents aged 30 to 59 in 2000 who did not have cardiovascular disease or diabetes at the start of the study. In addition, they looked at 41,944 people who had already been diagnosed with cardiometabolic disease, which includes heart disease and metabolic conditions such as diabetes. They followed them all until the end of 2014 to see who developed or died from these conditions.
What the researchers say: "We found that among healthy individuals, those with a low educational level have a higher risk of developing cardiovascular disease than those with a high educational level. Among 10,000 men with low education, 61 would develop a cardiovascular disease within 12 months, whereas among 10,000 men with high education, only 34 would develop the disease within this time-frame. After taking variables that could affect the results into account, such as age and migration background, this corresponds to almost a 2-fold higher risk among those with low education.
"Among women the picture is similar, although overall working-age women have a much lower risk of cardiovascular disease than men."
The researchers also gathered information on annual disposable household incomes and "job strain," which is a combination of the psychological demands of a job and the amount of control a person has over their work. A job with high job strain would be one where there are high psychological demands, but little control.
Those with high job strain and low income were at high risk no matter what their education level was. However, those with a lower level education still came out worse.
The researchers found a similar pattern when they looked at people who had cardiovascular disease or diabetes when the study started.
"If low income and high job strain play a role in how educational level affects risk of cardiovascular disease, then improvement of disposable income and reduction of job strain may help to reduce the increased risk of developing or dying from cardiovascular disease among people with low educational attainment,” said the lead author.
"Furthermore, ensuring equal treatment regardless of educational level is important, both in terms of preventing the development of cardiovascular disease amongst healthy people and of preventing death from cardiovascular disease amongst people who already have heart disease, diabetes or have suffered a stroke."
So, what? That job strain is a killer will not be news to any TR reader, or that low income leads to a multitude of health issues. However, inequality of education being a probable causal factor in cardiovascular problems is new, if not startling. The linkage of all three with the increasing death rate in the US and other countries is a cause of deep concern.
All three will be exacerbated by a number of factors: firstly, the increasing reliance on technological innovation rather than human labor; secondly climate change which will predominately affect the under educated, the poor and the unemployed; and finally, the increasing sense of despair which has led to the rise of fanaticism, intolerance and would-be tyrants in many parts of the world.
Well, I’ve got that off my chest! Whew, I feel better now.
More from this issue of TR
You might be interested in
Fear of disloyalty drives bias against bicultural immigrants
Fear of immigrants seems to be the dominant feeling exploited by so many politicians from Boris Johnson in the UK to Victor Orban in Hungary and to DT in the US (to name but a few). Recently scientists have been taking a closer look at the reasons that we are so afraid of those who are different to us
High rate of suicidal ideation in children
With 8% of US children aged 9-10 reporting suicidal ideation, greater effort is needed to protect children from early life adverse experiences.
Psychology, and psychometrics suffer from WEIRD science.
For decades, the consensus among psychologists (and those who frame psychometric tests) was that a cluster of five personality traits openness, conscientiousness, agreeableness, extraversion and neuroticism —or a slight variation thereof—universally defines the structure of human personality. However, when the team behind this research studied the Tsimane, an isolated indigenous population in the Bolivian Amazon, they found not five broad dimensions of personality, but two—prosociality and industriousness. Perhaps the Big Five aren’t so universal after all.
Join our tribe
Subscribe to Dr. Bob Murray’s Today’s Research, a free weekly roundup of the latest research in a wide range of scientific disciplines. Explore leadership, strategy, culture, business and social trends, and executive health.