Recruiting male allies boosts women at work
Listen to this article
A new study shows that when women and men raise their voices together in the workplace, managers are more likely to support gender equity issues, such as equal pay for equal work.
The researchers surveyed 3,234 participants during three separate studies. They asked each group a different set of questions about a range of gender equity proposals, from training women in how to negotiate for higher pay to ensuring that women formed at least 50% of the candidates for leadership positions.
In each of the three studies, participants — including those in managerial roles — reacted more favorably overall to mixed-gender coalitions than to women-only or men-only advocates. This is because:
- Mixed-gender coalitions (owing to the participation of men) were able to signal that gender equity is an important issue for the organization.
- Mixed-gender coalitions (owing to the participation of women) were able to signal that they had the right to speak up about gender equity issues.
What the researchers say: “This research addresses how best to form an advocacy group to raise these issues, if you want to get results,” the lead researcher said. The study is in the Academy of Management Journal.
Managers see women as legitimate messengers, she said, because they have personal interests in an issue. But adding men makes the message itself appear more legitimate by indicating that it matters to a wider range of stakeholders.
“When only women advocate for gender equity, it can come across as a niche concern,” she explained. “When men speak up about it, they can be seen as lacking the right to protest an issue that doesn’t personally concern them. It’s really when you bring women and men together as advocates that you circumvent both concerns.”
The researchers noted that the effect was limited to women’s issues. When managers were asked to take actions on nongender equity issues, such as training to improve customer service skills, mixed-gender coalitions showed no advantage.
But the lesson might apply beyond women’s issues. Other kinds of socially charged workplace concerns, such as racial justice, could potentially benefit from demographically diverse coalitions. For instance, if a group is trying to advance racial equity in the workplace, a coalition of white and Black employees might be better able to signal both coalition legitimacy and issue legitimacy.
Although women have yet to reach equality in many workplaces, the researchers were encouraged at how seriously the participants took women’s proposals. On the scale from 0 to 7, their levels of support ranged from 4.47 to 5.43.
“If we had run this study 10 or 20 years ago, we might have uncovered much poorer attitudes toward gender equity in general,” the researchers said. “And as the workplace is always evolving, these findings may change 10 or 20 years from now, with more social progress. At least today, though, it helps to recruit men as allies. Gender equity advocacy is most effective when women and men work together.”
So, what? This is an important study, even if the conclusions are somewhat obvious. Many studies have shown that you get further with any social cause if you enlist the help of the dominant social group.
At the moment that dominant social group—at least in the US, Australasia and Western Europe—is white male.
Join the discussion
More from this issue of TR
How to easily lose money on the market
Specialized ETFs which invest in specific popular industries or themes are based mostly on hype and tend to lose value almost as soon as they are launched.
Recruiting male allies boosts women at work
When women and men raise their voices together in the workplace, managers are more likely to support gender equity issues.
You might be interested inBack to Today's Research
Women suffer more mistreatment, burnout, suicidal thoughts
Any occupation previously dominated by men usually has among the highest rates of abuse against women.
Mumpreneur (or mompreneur) success still requires conventional masculine behavior
Whilst the mumpreneur identity may enable women to participate in the business world and be recognized as ‘proper’ entrepreneurs, this success is dependent on alignment with the conventional masculine norms of entrepreneurship, such as working long hours and an ongoing dedicated commitment to the success of a business.
Gender differences in brain in response to midlife stress linked to fetal stress exposures
A mother’s stress during pregnancy can result in a child born depressed or clinically anxious - but that was assumed to be temporary. However, men and women whose mothers experienced stressful events during pregnancy have been found to regulate stress differently in the brain 45 years later.
Join our tribe
Subscribe to Dr. Bob Murray’s Today’s Research, a free weekly roundup of the latest research in a wide range of scientific disciplines. Explore leadership, strategy, culture, business and social trends, and executive health.