Humans who experience early life adversity suffer as adults. Why are gorillas more resilient?
Listen to this article
This may be the most important study of the week—or maybe year. It helps us to understand why negative early life experiences can shorten longevity in humans and many other species—including dogs. But apparently there’s something different about gorillas which we can learn from in terms of resilience.
Previous studies revealed that young gorillas are surprisingly resilient to losing their mothers, in contrast to what has been found in many other species. But losing your mother is only one of many potential bad things that can happen to young animals.
What the researchers say: "Assuming that you survive something that we consider early life adversity, it's often still the case that you will be less healthy or you will have fewer kids or your lifespan will be shorter—no matter what species you are," said the senior author on the study. "There's this whole range of things that happens to you that seems to just make your life worse in adulthood."
Contrary to human lack of resilience after adverse childhood events the researchers found that gorillas who survived past age 6 were largely unaffected by difficulties they encountered as infants or juveniles. The study is published in the journal Current Biology.
Like other species, humans also deal with early life adversity, and the effects of this can follow us into adulthood, resulting in a shorter lifespan and/or mental and physical health complications, the researchers note. But in humans, it's difficult to tease out whether we, for example, develop cancer or die early as adults because of an adverse event early in life per se, or whether it's because of a multitude of behavioral, environmental, and cultural factors—or a combination of all of the above.
Studying these early adverse events in nonhuman species could help researchers understand how such events affect humans, and how to mitigate them.
"When you look at animals, you remove a lot of the variation that we have in humans. For example, they are all eating similar diets, they all get exercise as part of their daily lives, they don't have the opportunity to engage in behaviors with negative health outcomes like smoking," the researchers said.
However, in most species it is still the case that early adversity can have negative effects in adulthood, which suggests that there is some kind of deeper biological mechanism there that we don't understand very well. That gorillas show a different pattern suggests these early life adversities can be overcome. Understanding why and how this happens can have significant implications for our own species, the lead author suggested.
Like humans, gorillas live a long time and have a small number of offspring that they heavily invest in. This makes them a good comparative animal model for understanding the ramifications of early life adverse events. The researchers looked at 55 years of long-term data collected in 253 wild mountain gorillas, 135 of which were male and 118 female. These gorillas live in Volcanoes National Park in Rwanda and have been monitored for more than five decades by the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund.
The researchers identified six different kinds of early life adversity: losing a father or mother, experiencing the death of a group member by infanticide (which other research has shown happens frequently among gorillas), social group instability, having few age-mates in the social group, and having a competing sibling who was born soon after them. The data included information about how many of these early adversities each gorilla experienced and at what age, as well as how long each gorilla lived.
The researchers looked at what happened when a gorilla experienced none, one, two or three or more adverse events. They found that the more of these adverse events gorillas experienced before age 6, the more likely they were to die as juveniles. But if, despite experiencing early adversity, they survived until age 6—past their juvenile stage—the researchers found no evidence that their lifespans were shorter, no matter how many adverse events the gorillas suffered.
In fact, if a gorilla experienced three or more forms of adversity, it actually lived longer; this group of animals had a 70% reduction in the risk of death across adulthood. But this was driven by greater longevity in males specifically, and the researchers suspect the trend was due to something called viability selection. This means that if a gorilla was strong enough to survive difficult early life events, it might just be a "higher-quality individual," and thus more likely to have a longer life span.
"I was expecting to see that these gorillas would have short lifespans and would not do very well as adults," the lead researcher told us. "We found that these events are definitely associated with a much higher risk of death when you're young. But if you survive to age 6, there's no evidence that those shorten your lifespan at all. This is quite different from what we see in other species." Including humans.
The researchers have some theories about why these mountain gorillas were so resilient. Gorillas have very tight-knit social groups and prior studies have shown that when a young gorilla loses its mom, it doesn't actually become more isolated: other gorillas fill the gap in social companionship.
"The youngster actually increases its time near other gorillas after the loss of its mom and in particular the highest-ranking adult male, even if he isn't their biological father," she said. "These strong networks might provide critical social buffering, as has been shown in humans. The quality of our social relationships is a very important predictor of our health and longevity—in some cases, more important than genetics or lifestyle."
Another reason they may be relatively buffered from the consequences of adversity is that mountain gorillas live in a resource-rich environment compared to many other wild primates. It may be easier for a gorilla to survive difficult circumstances if they are also not constantly dealing with the stress of finding enough food and water.
The researchers' findings suggest that species similar to our own can have significant resilience to early life adversity. The results also raise important questions about the biological roots of sensitivity to early experiences, and the protective mechanisms that contribute to resilience in gorillas.
"I don't think we should assume that the long-term negative effects of early life adversity are universal," the lead author said. "We tend to talk about this as if it's a ubiquitous experience, and a given that your adulthood is going to be compromised if you live through early adversity.
"But I don't think it's nearly that cut-and-dry, even in the human literature. I think the data are a lot more complex for humans and this research would suggest that they might be more complex for other animals, too. And I actually think that that's a hopeful story.”
So, what? I have personally noticed a very similar situation to the gorillas in hunter-gatherer bands. There is a high risk of early death, but those individuals that survive to adulthood generally have a long and relatively healthy life.
The characteristics that they share with mountain gorillas is that the nuclear family is not the closed unit that it is in our society, there is an abundance of food and other necessities of life and there is a deep sense of belonging to the group.
The bottom line is that an animal can survive youth adversity and be resilient if it is surrounded by supportive relationships within the community and if it doesn’t have constant survival stress—such as a lack of food.
The relational support that gorillas and H-G humans have is close and personal. Our relationships are becoming less and less so with the rise of the internet, social media and a mass society.
Suicide is virtually unknown in H-G or gorilla societies and yet is rapidly becoming a main cause of death in ours—up there with cancer and cardiovascular disease.
The bottom line is that gorillas and H-G humans live in ways and contexts that are closer to their design specs and therefore are more resilient and less stressed. That’s the lesson for us all.
Join the discussion
More from this issue of TR
Psychopathic traits behind the rise and fall of Madoff
"There are likely to be plenty of people in the world of corporate finance with similar psychopathic traits to Bernie Madoff."
"Divine" legislation mapped: Religion blocks freedom and democracy across the globe
"Societies with greater social inequality are more likely to worship gods that are attributed with a dominant character."
You might be interested inBack to Today's Research
Firefighters can ease one another's job stress, but loving spouses may increase it
Strong same-sex friendships among male firefighters can help cut down on their stress—but loving relationships with their wives may increase anxiety for those who constantly face danger.
Despite flexibility, gig work proves harmful to workers
Insecure income from gig work contributed to poor health outcomes, including a sicker workforce, higher unreimbursed healthcare costs and greater costs to the consumer.
Join our tribe
Subscribe to Dr. Bob Murray’s Today’s Research, a free weekly roundup of the latest research in a wide range of scientific disciplines. Explore leadership, strategy, culture, business and social trends, and executive health.